From Burden to Breakthrough: Reimagining Document Review

Part 1: Transforming Your Greatest Cost Center into a Strategic Asset

“I need 20 reviewers by Monday.”

These six words have struck fear into the hearts of legal operations professionals for decades. What follows is all too familiar: frantic calls to staffing agencies, days of waiting for candidates, staggering markups, and the gnawing uncertainty about quality and consistency.

As Legal Week 2025 approaches, it’s time to ask a radical question: What if document review could become your competitive advantage rather than your biggest headache?

When “The Way It’s Always Been Done” No Longer Works

Picture this scenario: It’s Thursday afternoon when a critical matter lands on your desk. The court has set an aggressive discovery timeline. Your outside counsel estimates you’ll need at least 15 reviewers working through the weekend.

The traditional approach unfolds like a painful script we all know by heart:

  • The urgent calls begin: You contact multiple staffing agencies, each promising quick results
  • The waiting game: Days pass as candidates are sourced and credentials are manually verified
  • The budget blow: You receive proposals with 40-60% markups on hourly rates
  • The quality gamble: You have limited visibility into reviewer qualifications or past performance
  • The inevitable delays: Monday morning arrives with only a portion of your team in place

According to industry data, the average time to fill temporary legal positions is approximately 6 days. For time-sensitive matters, this delay isn’t just inconvenient—it can be consequential for case outcomes and client relationships.

“We were consistently starting our reviews 3-5 days later than needed,” shares the litigation support director at an AmLaw 100 firm. “In high-stakes matters, that lost time was creating real downstream pressure on our attorneys and damaging our client relationships.”

The Technology Inflection Point

The good news? We’re experiencing a fundamental transformation in how document review can be sourced, managed, and optimized.

The emergence of specialized legal staffing platforms has compressed what once took days into minutes:

  • Credential verification: Bar status and jurisdictional requirements confirmed instantly
  • Reviewer deployment: Qualified reviewers sourced and confirmed in an average of 2.5 minutes
  • Performance tracking: Real-time productivity and quality metrics available throughout the review
  • Direct compensation: Elimination of traditional markups, reducing costs by 25-40%

This isn’t incremental improvement—it’s a paradigm shift that transforms document review from a necessary evil into a potential strategic advantage.

From Cost Center to Competitive Edge

Forward-thinking legal departments are leveraging these technological advances to reimagine document review in four powerful ways:

1. Cost as Opportunity, Not Just Expense

By eliminating traditional staffing markups and improving process efficiency, organizations aren’t just saving money—they’re creating new possibilities.

A corporate legal department we work with reduced annual document review costs by 37%. Instead of simply returning those savings to the corporate budget, they reinvested in expanding their investigation capabilities, turning a cost-cutting exercise into a strategic expansion of their legal function.

2. Speed as Leverage

When reviewers can be deployed in minutes rather than days, legal teams gain a significant advantage in time-sensitive matters:

“We were able to begin review within hours of receiving a second request in an acquisition context,” notes the general counsel of a technology company. “That speed allowed us to identify potential issues early and adjust our negotiation strategy accordingly. Document review actually became a strategic input rather than just a compliance exercise.”

3. Quality Through Visibility

Real-time metrics on reviewer accuracy, consistency, and productivity are transforming quality control:

  • Identifying top performers for future projects
  • Addressing quality concerns before they impact outcomes
  • Ensuring consistency across large review teams
  • Creating defensible, documented review processes

“We’ve built a preferred team of reviewers who understand our business and documents,” explains a litigation counsel at a financial services firm. “Their familiarity with our industry terminology and documents has improved accuracy while reducing the time our attorneys spend providing guidance.”

4. Knowledge as an Asset

Rather than starting from scratch with each new matter, progressive legal departments are building institutional knowledge:

  • Creating proprietary databases of qualified reviewers
  • Tracking subject matter expertise for specialized reviews
  • Maintaining relationships with high-performing reviewers
  • Developing standardized workflows for common review types

Finding Your Place on the Independence Spectrum

Not every organization has the same goals or capabilities. We’re seeing legal departments position themselves along what we call the “independence spectrum”:

  • Full-Service Management: Some organizations prefer to outsource the entire review process to experts who handle everything from staffing to quality control.
  • Hybrid Approach: Others maintain control over key decisions like reviewer selection while outsourcing administrative functions.
  • Complete Independence: The most advanced departments build fully independent review operations, maintaining their own reviewer databases and managing the entire process in-house.

There’s no one-size-fits-all solution. The right approach depends on your organization’s volume of review projects, internal resources, and strategic goals.

The Journey Forward

As we approach Legal Week 2025, the question isn’t whether document review will transform, but how quickly legal departments will adapt to the new possibilities.

In our next article, we’ll explore how leading organizations are building their document review independence roadmap—creating a strategic plan to move from traditional staffing dependencies toward greater control, efficiency, and quality.

This is the first installment in our four-part series exploring the transformation of legal document review. Stay tuned for Part 2: “Building Your Document Review Independence Roadmap.”

Related Posts

Empowering Planners with
Precision Tools

credential-verification-image